Buying a Carcharocles megalodon tooth online is exciting. You’re not just shopping for a “cool shark tooth.” You’re choosing a real fossil that has survived for millions of years. That also means you need to be a bit careful. There are many sellers, many prices, and many quality levels. Some fossils are top-grade. Some are heavily repaired. Some are not worth the money at all. With a few simple checks, you can avoid common beginner mistakes and feel confident about what you’re buying.
Mistake 1: Skipping the Seller Check
Many beginners look only at the tooth and ignore who is selling it. This is risky.
Before you buy, always check the seller:
● Do they specialize in fossils, especially shark teeth?
● Do they show clear, close-up photos of the exact tooth?
● Do they give a full description (size, location, condition)?
● Do they sound knowledgeable about Carcharocles megalodon and fossil grading?
Trusted dealers like Buried Treasure Fossils build their business around real, well-described specimens. If a seller looks new, vague, or “too good to be true,” it’s better to move on.
Mistake 2: Ignoring Repairs and Restorations
Not every Carcharocles megalodon tooth is 100% natural and untouched. Many fossils have:
● Glued breaks
● Filled chips
● Rebuilt tips or roots
Repairs and restorations are not always bad. They can make a damaged fossil look complete and easier to display. The problem comes when a buyer thinks they are getting a “perfect natural tooth” but it’s actually heavily restored.
In the product description, look for phrases like:
● “No repair / no restoration”
● “Minor repair to root”
● “Restored enamel and tip”
Honest dealers clearly state what has been done. If you’re not sure, ask. If the seller avoids the question, that’s a sign to step away.
Mistake 3: Only Caring About Size
Yes, a big tooth looks impressive. But when it comes to Carcharocles megalodon teeth, bigger is not always better.
A smaller tooth in excellent condition can be much more attractive and valuable than a large tooth with:
● A broken tip
● Heavy wear
● Weak or missing serrations
● Cracked enamel
When comparing teeth, check:
● Tip – Is it sharp and complete?
● Serrations – Are they visible and fairly even?
● Enamel – Is it smooth and glossy, or dull and flaking?
● Root – Does it look solid and natural, not overly filled or reshaped?
A good dealer will grade and price teeth based on overall quality, not just size. This is where shopping with a specialist seller really helps.
Mistake 4: Not Reading the Full Description
Another common mistake is to look at the photos and skip the text. The description often tells you key facts that the photos can’t.
For each Carcharocles megalodon tooth, read the full description and check for:
● Location – Where was the tooth found? (e.g., specific country or region)
● Age – The geological age or time period
● Exact size – Length measured clearly (often to the nearest 1/16" or millimeter)
● Condition notes – Any chips, repairs, wear, or special features
Two teeth might look similar in size in pictures but be very different in condition or origin. Those details often explain the price. Sellers like Buried Treasure Fossils usually include very clear notes, so make use of that information before you buy.
Final Thoughts
Buying Carcharocles’ megalodon teeth online doesn’t have to be complicated. If you check the seller, pay attention to repairs and think about care and policies, you’ll avoid the most common rookie mistakes. With these basics in mind—and by choosing trusted fossil specialists like Buried Treasure Fossils—you can build a collection of Carcharocles megalodon teeth that you’ll be proud to own and display for years.
