If you’re asking how much is a megalodon tooth, the short answer is: it depends on size, condition, locality, and, yes, standout color and luster. On Buried Treasure Fossils, vividly colored or glossy, museum-grade pieces command premium prices. Below, you’ll see real examples from the site to anchor expectations, plus a simple checklist to judge value the same way a seasoned collector would.
Why Color and Luster Change The Price
Color isn’t just “nice to have.” It signals the mineral chemistry and preservation of the sediment where the tooth fossilized. Jet blacks, copper reds, creamy tans, blue-and-tan gradients, and high-gloss enamel can lift a specimen into a higher tier, especially when matched with size and crisp serrations. Buried Treasure Fossils highlights these traits in its listings and organizes teeth by celebrated localities and color categories, including BLACK Megalodon, Copper Red (Meherrin River, NC), Caribbean light-toned enamel, Sharktooth Hill blue-and-tan pieces, and more.
Real Prices from Buried Treasure Fossils
Here are verified examples that show what premium color and sheen look like and what they cost on the site:
● Caribbean light-toned enamel (near-white look), 6-1/16″ – Listed at $4,995.00 is a “very light tan” crown with charcoal/red-brown highlights, a white bourlette, fantastic color, and razor-sharp serrations. Museum Quality.
● Indonesia, bold color and gloss, 6-1/8″ – Listed at $4,750.00 is a BLACK with silver & tan crown, excellent bourlette, and razor-sharp serrations. A “very special color collector’s” piece.
● Sharktooth Hill (California), blue & tan, 5-3/4″ – Listed at $4,500.00 highlights highest quality enamel with a great Blue & Tan color, near-complete bourlette, and complete serrations, an extremely rare STH Meg.
● Georgia, dark gray & blue, heavy 6-5/16″ – Listed at $4,250.00, notes excellent Dark Gray & Blue color, black bourlette, extra-thick root, and sharp serrations. Weighs over 1.25 lbs.
● Meherrin River, North Carolina “Copper Red,” 6″ – Listed at $4,250.00, this one is marketed as “Exceptional rich copper red color.” Ultra-rare red-site piece with large, sharp serrations and wide, complete root.
What If You’re Starting Out?
If you want authenticity without the four-figure spend, Buried Treasure Fossils has a “My First Megalodon” section, great condition, smaller sizes, and accessible pricing. Current offerings in that section include framed Florida or South Carolina Megalodon teeth typically around $130–$150 on live product pages (e.g., $150.00, $145.00, $135.00, $130.00). These are real Meg teeth with attractive color, sized for gifts, classrooms, and first collections.
Important Note: Pricing changes as inventory turns. The figures above are specific examples taken directly from product pages and category listings on the site at the time of writing. Always refer to the product page for current availability and price.
The Quick Collector Checklist
Use this simple list to evaluate the premium impact of color and enamel:
● Overall color: Jet black, copper red, light/near-white Caribbean tones, or striking blue-and-tan blends can lift price when the tooth also has size and condition.
● Enamel gloss (“luster”): High-gloss, crack-free enamel photographs beautifully and reads as superior preservation. This raises desirability.
● Bourlette completeness: A full, intact bourlette (the chevron area below the crown) is a plus, especially when it contrasts aesthetically with the crown color.
● Serrations & tip: Sharp, complete serrations, including the tip serration, signal less wear and higher grade. Color shines more when edge detail is crisp.
● Root symmetry & thickness: A wide, complete, nicely articulated root frames color and sheen, improving the display presence.
● Locality cachet: “Copper Red” (NC), Sharktooth Hill (CA), Caribbean light enamel, and select Indonesian sites are celebrated for distinctive looks that often command more.
How Much is a Megalodon Tooth with Rare Color?
Let’s bring it together with the specific use-case you’re researching:
● If you find a large tooth (5.5–6″+) with unusual, saturated color and clean, glossy enamel, you’re looking at several thousand dollars on this site. The $4,995 Caribbean 6-1/16″, $4,750 Indonesian 6-1/8″ (black/silver/tan), $4,500 Sharktooth Hill 5-3/4″ (blue & tan), and $4,250 Copper Red 6″ NC offerings are strong reference points for the premium that rare color plus luster can add.
● If you want a budget-friendly but authentic Meg tooth, the My First Megalodon listings around $130–$150 are ideal. These typically feature smaller sizes but can still show pleasing color and shine.
What the Buried Treasure Fossils Actually Sells
Buried Treasure Fossils is a specialist dealer in authentic fossils, Megalodon teeth are a core category alongside other shark species, dinosaur fossils, and museum-grade pieces. Within Megalodon, you can browse by locality (Florida, Georgia, Lee Creek, North Carolina Copper Red, South Carolina, Sharktooth Hill, Chile, Peru, Indonesia, Caribbean), by color category (including BLACK), by size (including 6″+), and by grade (including Museum Quality). This structure helps you filter for the color/luster combinations you want and cross-check price tiers.
Buying TIps Specific to Color and Luster
● Match color to provenance. “Copper Red” should come from the Meherrin River red site; the Caribbean pieces often show near-white to pale enamel; Sharktooth Hill material is renowned and scarce; Indonesian teeth can show dramatic two-tone or black-accented crowns. Provenance that explains the color adds confidence—and value.
● Prioritize enamel integrity. High luster is best when it’s natural and paired with intact bourlette and edges. Read listing notes carefully for any professional restoration and where it occurs.
● Weigh display presence. A big color needs a good frame: symmetrical root, wide crown, and crisp edges. Those traits make rare coloration “pop,” justifying premium prices.
Final Word
So, how much is a megalodon tooth when rare color and exceptional luster enter the picture? On Buried Treasure Fossils, expect high four-figure pricing for large, museum-grade teeth with standout hues and glossy enamel, with multiple real listings between $4,250 and $4,995 illustrating that premium. If you’re just getting started, authentic smaller teeth around $130–$150 let you enjoy real color and shine without the museum-grade price tag. All examples above are pulled directly from the site’s product pages and categories so you can shop confidently and avoid guesswork.
