Authentic Fossil Shark Teeth for Sale
Find an impressive variety of high-quality shark teeth for sale, perfect for both serious collectors and enthusiasts of natural history. The selection features some of the most sought-after specimens, including massive Megalodon teeth, sharp Angustidens, and the distinctive Hemipristis, also known as the Snaggletooth. From the prehistoric Otodus to modern Great White and Mako shark teeth, each piece is legally collected and carefully inspected to ensure its quality and provenance.
Collectors can browse rare and unique finds, including the serrated Auriculatus, deep-water Cow shark teeth, and ancient Paleozoic specimens. Every item comes with a guarantee of authenticity, providing confidence in the value of the acquisition. Whether looking for a centerpiece for a display or a unique gift, this curated inventory offers a wide array of genuine fossilized teeth that connect you directly to the ocean's ancient predators.
- Otodus chubutensis$125.00
A QUALITY copper red colored Chubutensis tooth from the Meherrin River red site, No. Carolina. Rare copper red colors! The bourlette is complete. The serrations are sharp. Complete root. Excellent color! A rare collector's tooth! Authenticity guaranteed.
NC056 SIZE: 1-7/8"
Learn More
Note - Adding 10 NC red site Chubutensis teeth in September 2022. Link to NC Chubutensis teeth. - Megalodon - My First Megalodon$125.00
A Quality Charcoal Gray colored Megalodon tooth from So. Carolina with frame. Good color. These Megalodon teeth are great for gifts, class room, or starting your fossil shark tooth or Megalodon collection. These Megs are Miocene age - about 15 MYA (Hawthorne Fm.) from So. Carolina unless otherwise marked. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. Note - All larger "First Megalodon" teeth come with a 4-1/2"x 5-1/2" Riker frame with label (as photographed) plus an identification card. Note - Be sure to see all of our My First Megalodon offerings.
MFM16 Size: 2-3/4"
Note - Adding 19 new My First Megalodon teeth in October 2022 -> Link to My First Megalodon
Learn More - Megalodon - My First Megalodon$125.00
A Top Quality Megalodon tooth from So. Carolina with frame. Great color. These Megalodon teeth are great for gifts, class room, or starting your fossil shark tooth or Megalodon collection. These Megs are Miocene age - about 15 MYA (Hawthorne Fm.) from So. Carolina unless otherwise marked. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. Note - All larger "First Megalodon" teeth come with a 4-1/2"x 5-1/2" Riker frame with label (as photographed) plus an identification card. Note - Be sure to see all of our My First Megalodon offerings.
MFM19 Size: 2-3/8"
Note - Adding 19 new My First Megalodon teeth in November 2023 -> Link to My First Megalodon
Learn More - Carcharodon hastalis - Golden Beach$125.00
A Top Quality, BLUE Bone Valley Mako shark tooth from Golden Beach, Florida. Lower jaw anterior tooth. Commonly referred to as Isurus hastalis, but renamed to Carcharodon hastalis as a Great White shark ancestor. Highest quality enamel. A glossy blue colored crown and an excellent tan root. Great color! Sharp cutting edges. Excellent eye appeal. A rare Bone Valley collector's Mako tooth. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. You don't see these Mako teeth very often!
F116 SIZE: 2-5/16"
Note - Adding 16 Golden Beach / Venice Beach Mako teeth in April 2024. -> Link to BV Isurus hastalis teeth
Learn More - Carcharocles auriculatus - Suwanee$125.00
A rare,Top Quality Suwanee Auriculatus tooth from northern Florida. An exceptional upper jaw lateral tooth. Gorgeous tan colored crown with a brown colored bourlette, and brown root. Highest quality enamel. Excellent color & preservation. The serrations are large and sharp with a slightly worn tip serration. The root is complete. It is very hard to find these teeth in perfect condition. An excellent collector's Suwanee River Auriculatus tooth! Authenticity guaranteed.
F447 SIZE: 1-3/4"
Note - Adding 15 Suwanee / Florida Auriculatus teeth in January 2022. Link to the Suwanee Auriculatus teeth.
Learn More - Shark Tooth Pendant$125.00
A Top Quality fossil Mako shark tooth necklace pendant from So. Carolina. This tooth has a tan color. This pendant is professionally created and includes a sterling silver cap & bail (.925 sterling). This is an authentic Pliocene fossil shark tooth. This is a very special pendant for your special gentleman friend or yourself. Very showy. Makes an excellent gift. Type: Mako
Item: SC16J Size: 1-9/16”
Note - Adding 8 SC shark tooth necklaces in May 2024. --> Link to SC fossil necklaces.
Learn More - Isurus hastalis - Peru$125.00
A colorful, Top Quality Carcharodon hastalis tooth from the Ica region of Peru. An incredible brown colored crown and a white root. Very good color! Sharp cutting edges. Excellent definition and preservation. An excellent lower jaw anterior tooth. No repair. Authenticity guaranteed. An excellent colorful collector's Mako tooth.
P316 SIZE: 1-7/8"
Adding 17 Carcharodon hastalis teeth in May 2024. Link to Peruvian Hastalis teeth.
Learn More - Isurus hastalis - Peru$125.00
A colorful, Top Quality Carcharodon hastalis tooth from the Ica region of Peru. An incredible dark blue colored crown and a gray root. Very good color! Sharp cutting edges. Excellent definition and preservation. An excellent upper jaw tooth. No repair. Authenticity guaranteed. An excellent colorful collector's Mako tooth.
P306 SIZE: 2-5/16"
Adding 17 Carcharodon hastalis teeth in May 2024. Link to Peruvian Hastalis teeth.
Learn More - Otodus angustidens$125.00
A Top Quality Angustidens - upper jaw anterior tooth from So. Carolina. Highest quality enamel. Bourlette is an excellent brown color and complete. Excellent serrations and side cusps. The root is very good and complete. Excellent OLIVE color and preservation. No repair or restoration. An Oligocene age tooth from the Chandler Bridge Formation. Authenticity guaranteed. Near perfect tooth.
SC504 SIZE: 2-5/8" (2-1/16' wide)
Note - Adding 17 new Angustidens teeth in October 2024. --> Link to Angustidens teeth.
Learn More - Isurus hastalis (Carcharodon hastalis)$125.00
A Top Quality, Carcharodon hastalis, Mako shark tooth (upper jaw tooth) from the Lee Creek mine, Aurora, No. Carolina. This tooth has a rich blue & tan crown and a gray colored root. Excellent colors! Razor sharp cutting edge. Wide crown. Excellent preservation - note nutrient hole on root. It is a Pliocene tooth from the Yorktown Fm. An excellent collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed.
LC308 Size: 2-3/8"
Note - Adding 30 new Lee Creek Big "Mako" teeth in February 2023. Link to Lee Creek Mako Teeth.
Learn More - Isurus oxyrinchus - Shortfin Mako$125.00
A LARGE Top Quality, Isurus oxyrinchus, the Shortfin Mako shark tooth (upper jaw anterior tooth) from the Lee Creek mine, Aurora, No. Carolina. This tooth has a brown & tan crown and a light brown colored root. Excellent colors! Razor sharp cutting edge. Excellent preservation - note nutrient hole on root. It is a Pliocene tooth from the Yorktown Fm. An excellent collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed.
LC353 Size: 2-1/16"
Note - Adding 20 new Lee Creek Shortfin Mako teeth in February 2023. Link to Lee Creek Oxyrinchus Mako Teeth.
Learn More - Notorhynchus cepedianus - Sevengill Cow$125.00
A Top Quality upper jaw Notorhynchus tooth - a Sevengill Cow shark, from the Lee Creek mine, Aurora, No. Carolina. Note - this is an upper lateral tooth with 6 main cusps. I rarely see this tooth position. This tooth has a rich blue & tan crown with a tan root. Incredible color and preservation. These are Miocene age, Pungo River Formation teeth. A Perfect tooth. A fantastic collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed.
LC623 Size: 3/4"
Note - Adding 39 Lee Creek Cow Shark teeth in February 2023 Link to Lee Creek Cow shark teeth.
Learn More
