Authentic Fossil Shark Teeth for Sale

A rare, Top Quality Phoebodus sp., an extinct Phoebodontiform shark tooth, from the Paleozoic era in Indiana. An excellent primary cusp. Great color and articulation. A well preserved specimen. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. An excellent collector's tooth! 

Age: Middle Mississippian (347 MYA); Harrodsburg Limestone Fm.

Location: Washington Co., Indiana

Z019      SIZE: 3/8"

Adding 30 US Paleozoic teeth in July 2025  -->  Link to US Paleozoic teeth

A rare, Top Quality Phoebodus sp., an extinct Phoebodontiform shark tooth, from the Paleozoic era in Indiana. An excellent primary cusp. Great color and articulation. A well preserved specimen. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. An excellent collector's tooth! 

Age: Middle Mississippian (347 MYA); Harrodsburg Limestone Fm.

Location: Washington Co., Indiana

Z020      SIZE: 5/16"

Adding 30 US Paleozoic teeth in July 2025  -->  Link to US Paleozoic teeth

A LARGE rare, High Quality Petalodus alleghaniensis, an extinct Petalodont shark tooth, from the Paleozoic era in Iowa. An excellent primary cusp. Great color and articulation. A well preserved specimen with some damage. No restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. An excellent collector's tooth! 

Age: Upper Pennsylvanian (300 MYA); Herta Limestone Fm.

Location: Crescent, Pottawattamie Co., Iowa

Z030       SIZE: 1-7/16" wide  x 1-3/4"

Adding 30 US Paleozoic teeth in July 2025  -->  Link to US Paleozoic teeth

A very rare, Top Quality Edestus heinrichi shark tooth, from Herrin, Illinois. This is a Paleozoic shark that lived in swamps that our now underground coal deposits. Excellent preservation, serrations, and serration detail. The Edestus shark would have an upper and lower tooth whorl that are vertically opposed. Research showed that they could use their opposing teeth in a scissor-like motion or a vertical whipping motion to cut prey. It is the first animal to cut vertically. A very strange looking and unique acting shark. Shark recreation image is credited to Julio Lacerdo. These rare teeth are Pennsylvanian age from Illinois. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. 

I23          SIZE:  1-7/8"  w/ root  (7/8" crown)

Adding 22 Edestus shark specimens in July 2025.    Link to Edestus shark.

A very rare Glyphis glyphis tooth, the Speartooth shark, from Sumatra, Indonesia. These teeth were deposited in the Telisa formation - a shallow marine environment during the middle Miocene (approx. 15 million years ago.) A very unique collector's tooth. D177 is an excellent upper jaw anterior tooth. Note - "spear-like" crown development. My best upper jaw tooth! Authenticity guaranteed.

D177        SIZE: 1/2"

Note - 16 new Sumatran Glyphis glyphis teeth added in January 2018.       Link to Sumatran teeth.

A Top Quality, Pristiophorous lanceolatus, Saw shark rostal tooth from the Bahia Iglesa Fm. of Chile. The crown is exceptionally clean and sharp. This Saw shark - Pristiophorous lanceolatus is a from late Miocene deposit. Beautiful color and fantastic preservation! Near maximum size. Authenticity guaranteed. You don't see quality Neogene Saw shark rostal teeth very often. Check out my new Blog - The Best of Chile - Shark Teeth   https://www.buriedtreasurefossils.com/blog/post/the-best-of-chile-fossil-shark-teeth/

C501              SIZE: 1-11/16"

Note - Posting 6 new Pristiophorous rostal teeth in Mar. 2020  ->  Chilean Saw Shark Teeth 

A Top Quality Ptychodus mammillaris tooth from Ness Co., Kansas. An excellent example of this Cretaceous shark. Authenticity guaranteed. Perfect tooth.

KS363           SIZE: 9/16" x 9/16"

Note - Adding 3 new P. mammillaris teeth in April 2020.   Link to Kansas P. mammillaris teeth

A Top Quality Ptychodus mammillaris tooth from Ellis Co., Kansas. An excellent example of this Cretaceous shark. Authenticity guaranteed. Near Perfect tooth.

KS362           SIZE: 9/16" x 9/16"

Note - Adding 3 new P. mammillaris teeth in April 2020.   Link to Kansas P. mammillaris teeth

An LARGE, TOP QUALITY, Isurus oxyrhincus tooth, the Shortfin Mako, from the Meherrin River, No. Carolina. Upper jaw lateral tooth. Excellent copper red color with exceptional gloss. The root shows very nice detail including one side dentical. Absolutely great preservation and condition - extra sharp edges and tip - very clean. Authenticity guaranteed.  Exceptional color!     

NC371              SIZE: 1-7/16"

Note - Adding 7 NC Red I. oxyrhinchus teeth in July 2020. Link to NC Red Oxyrhinchus teeth.

An EXTRA LARGE, TOP QUALITY, Isurus oxyrhincus tooth, the Shortfin Mako, from the Meherrin River, No. Carolina. Upper jaw lateral tooth. Excellent copper red color with exceptional gloss. The root shows very nice detail including two side denticals. Absolutely great preservation and condition - extra sharp edges and tip - very clean. Authenticity guaranteed.  Exceptional color!     

NC368              SIZE: 1-11/16"

Note - Adding 7 NC Red I. oxyrhinchus teeth in July 2020. Link to NC Red Oxyrhinchus teeth.

An EXTRA LARGE, TOP QUALITY, Isurus oxyrhincus tooth, the Shortfin Mako, from the Meherrin River, No. Carolina. Upper jaw anterior tooth. Excellent copper red color with exceptional gloss. The root shows very nice detail. Absolutely great preservation and condition - extra sharp edges and tip - very clean. Authenticity guaranteed.  Exceptional color!     

NC365              SIZE: 1-15/16"

Note - Adding 7 NC Red I. oxyrhinchus teeth in July 2020. Link to NC Red Oxyrhinchus teeth.

A Top Quality wire wrapped Mako shark tooth necklace from So. Carolina. This necklace includes blue & black beads and a 20" leatherette cord with a simple clasp. This is an authentic Miocene fossil shark tooth. Excellent gifts!      Type: Mako

Item: SC11J      Size: 1-3/4”  

Note - Adding 12 SC shark tooth necklaces in May 2023. --> Link to SC fossil necklaces.