Authentic Fossil Shark Teeth for Sale

An ultra rare, Top Quality lower jaw lateral Hexanchus tooth - the Sixgill Cow shark, from the Lee Creek mine, Aurora, No. Carolina. This tooth has a rich blue & tan crown with a tan root. Eleven main cusps (all complete). Please note that this tooth is from a back up row. and the root is not fully developed.  Incredible color and preservation. These are Pliocene age, Yorktown Formation teeth. A Perfect tooth. A fantastic collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed. Complete Lee Creek Hexanchus teeth are rarely found, and this is the first time that I can offer them!

LC637         Size: 1-9/16"

Note - Adding 39 Lee Creek Cow Shark teeth in February 2023        Link to Lee Creek Cow shark teeth.

An ultra rare, Top Quality lower jaw lateral Hexanchus tooth - the Sixgill Cow shark, from the Lee Creek mine, Aurora, No. Carolina. This tooth has a rich orange -  tan crown with a light tan root. Nine main cusps (two have some damage). The root is incredible - damage free and thick. Incredible color and preservation. These are Pliocene age, Yorktown Formation teeth. A fantastic collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed. Complete Lee Creek Hexanchus teeth are rarely found, and this is the first time that I can offer them!

LC632         Size: 1-5/8"

Note - Adding 39 Lee Creek Cow Shark teeth in February 2023        Link to Lee Creek Cow shark teeth.

An EXTRA LARGE, Top Quality Carcharodon hastalis, the Broad-tooth Mako shark tooth from So.Carolina. Previously referred to as Isurus hastalis, but renamed to Carcharodon hastalis as a Great White shark ancestor. An October Fossil of the Month. Highest estquality enamel. A BLUE colored crown with a tan stripe above the root. Excellent color!  Sharp cutting edges. An excellent root – extra wide. Excellent symmetry. No repair or restoration. A fantastic color collector's BIG Mako tooth! Authenticity guaranteed.

SC302        SIZE: 3-1/8"   (2-1/16" wide)

Adding 18 SC Carcharodon hastalis teeth in October 2024.   ->  Link to SC Carcharodon hastalis teeth

A Quality, Megalodon tooth - an upper jaw tooth from the ACE River basin, South Carolina. An excellent BLACK colored crown. High quality enamel. The bourlette is a large and black color. The serrations are worn, but visible. The root is black color, wide, and  complete. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed.  A quality collector's Megalodon tooth. An excellent big Megalodon tooth!

SC006       Size: 5-1/8"  (4-1/8" wide)

Note - Adding 20 new SC Megalodon teeth in October 2025  ->  Link to SC Megalodon teeth.

An ULTRA RARE, "Dual Crown" PATHOLOGIC Megachasma tooth, the Megamouth shark, from the Bahia Iglesa Fm., Chile. An April Fossil of the Month. The Megamouth shark is a very rare and exotic fossil shark tooth since it is rarely found in the fossil record. Megachasma teeth are one of the scarce and well preserved fossils that are unique to the Caldera Basin site in Chile!  Late Miocene age. No repair or restoration. An exceptional and ultra rare collector's "Dual Crown"tooth! Authenticity guaranteed. My last and best dual crown tooth.

C558            Size: 5/8"  (Base  7/16" x 7/16")

Note - Adding 8 new Chilean Megachasma teeth in April 2026 -> Link to Megachasma teeth

The Color Collection. A Top Quality Great White shark tooth - upper jaw anterior tooth from Chile. This tooth has a Blue & Tan olored crown with tan serrations, a distinct gum line, and a burgundy colored root. Fantastic color.  Highest quality enamel with no hydration cracks and no peeling. Serrations are large with a great tip serration. Excellent preservation - note nutrient hole on root. An EXCELLENT color collector's Great White tooth. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. 

C202        Size: 2-3/8"

Note - Adding 15 Chilean Great White teeth in April 2026    Link to Great White shark teeth

A VERY RARE, Top Quality Hexanchus griseus tooth from the Caldera Basin of Chile. This is complete lower jaw tooth with a unique pathology. Superb preservation and color. Ten primary cusps fully formed on the left and nine cusps on the right. Very unusual. No repair or restoration. An excellent root - very unique & extremely difficult to find!  Authenticity guaranteed. Unfortunately there are no more teeth coming from this site. This rare piece is from an old collection.     

C404L          Size: 1-3/4"

Note - Adding 6 new Chilean Hexanchus teeth in May 2026 ->  Link to Hexanchus Teeth 

A RARE, EXTRA LARGE, Top Quality Hexanchus griseus tooth from the Caldera Basin of Chile. A May Fossil of ther Month. This is big, complete lower jaw tooth on its original matrix. Superb preservation and color. Thirteen primary cusps. No repair or restoration. An excellent root - very unique & extremely difficult to find!  Authenticity guaranteed. Unfortunately there are no more teeth coming from this site. This rare piece is from an old collection.     

C403L          Size: 1-15/16"

Note - Adding 6 new Chilean Hexanchus teeth in May 2026 ->  Link to Hexanchus Teeth 

An ULTRA RARE, Top Quality Hexanchus griseus symphyseal tooth from the Caldera Basin of Chile. A May Fossil of ther Month. This is a slightly pathologic lower symphyseal jaw tooth (center tooth) with 7 large primary cusps on the left side and small cusps on the right side. Superb preservation and color. No repair or restoration. An excellent root - very unique & extremely difficult to find!  Authenticity guaranteed. Unfortunately there are no more teeth coming from this site. This rare piece is from an old collection.     

C401L          Size: 7/8"

Note - Adding 6 new Chilean Hexanchus teeth in May 2026 ->  Link to Hexanchus Teeth 

A HUGE, High Quality Aetomylaeus sp., an Eagle ray, mouth plate from Caldera area of Chile. An April Fossil of the Month. An excellent plate of pavement teeth from the lower jaw. This plate has good preservation, light brown color, and is exceptionally clean. Note - the bottom side of this specimen is completely matrix free - rare. An incredibly sized late Miocene Eagle ray mouth plate from the Bahia Inglesa Fm.  Authenticity guaranteed. Unfortunately there are no more teeth coming from this site!

C951        SIZE: 8"  (4-1/2" Wide)

Note - Adding 4 Ray mouth plates in April 2022.  ->  Link to Chilean rays.

A rare, EXTRA LARGE Top Quality Hexanchus collinsonae tooth, a Sixgill Cow shark, from the Muddy Creek / Fisher - Sullivan site, Virginia.  A lower jaw tooth with 10 primary cusps. Exceptional color and preservation. This is an Early Eocene (Ypresian) age, Nanjemoy Formation tooth. A special collector's Cow shark tooth. Authenticity guaranteed. 

MC955         Size: 5/8"+

Note adding 15 Muddy Creek Cow shark teeth in June 2022.  --> Link to Muddy Creek Cow Shark teeth

A HIGH QUALITY, PATHOLOGIC Megalodon - upper jaw tooth from West Java, Indonesia. The serrated edge has a sharp crease in it. This Megalodon has an incredible charcoal & tan colored crown with large brown colored bourlette. Highest quality enamel. Fantastic color! The serrations are razor sharp with an excellent tip serrration. The root is near complete with some pits that happens with some West Java Megs. Miocene Age. No repair or restoration. Authenticity Guaranteed. 

IN64       Size: 4-9/16"  

Note - Adding 12 High Quality Indonesian Megalodon Teeth in July 2023.  ->   Link to HQ Indonesian Megs