Authentic Fossil Shark Teeth for Sale
Find an impressive variety of high-quality shark teeth for sale, perfect for both serious collectors and enthusiasts of natural history. The selection features some of the most sought-after specimens, including massive Megalodon teeth, sharp Angustidens, and the distinctive Hemipristis, also known as the Snaggletooth. From the prehistoric Otodus to modern Great White and Mako shark teeth, each piece is legally collected and carefully inspected to ensure its quality and provenance.
Collectors can browse rare and unique finds, including the serrated Auriculatus, deep-water Cow shark teeth, and ancient Paleozoic specimens. Every item comes with a guarantee of authenticity, providing confidence in the value of the acquisition. Whether looking for a centerpiece for a display or a unique gift, this curated inventory offers a wide array of genuine fossilized teeth that connect you directly to the ocean's ancient predators.
- Isurus retroflexus$70.00
A rare TOP QUALITY, Isurus retroflexus tooth, a Longfin Mako, from the Meherrin River, No. Carolina. Upper jaw lateral tooth. Excellent copper red color with exceptional gloss. The root shows very nice detail with the typical distinct enameloid build up on the reverse side. Absolutely great preservation and condition - extra sharp edges and tip - very clean. Authenticity guaranteed. Exceptional color!
NC391 SIZE: 1-5/16"
Learn More - Isurus oxyrhinchus$70.00
A LARGE, TOP QUALITY, Isurus oxyrhincus tooth, the Shortfin Mako, from the Meherrin River, No. Carolina. Upper jaw anterior tooth. Excellent copper red color with exceptional gloss. The root shows very nice detail. Absolutely great preservation and condition - extra sharp edges and tip - very clean. Authenticity guaranteed. Exceptional color!
NC363 SIZE: 1-11/16"
Learn More
Note - Adding 7 NC Red I. oxyrhinchus teeth in July 2020. Link to NC Red Oxyrhinchus teeth. - Isurus oxyrhinchus$70.00
An EXTRA LARGE, TOP QUALITY, Isurus oxyrhincus tooth, the Shortfin Mako, from the Meherrin River, No. Carolina. Upper jaw anterior tooth. Excellent copper red color with exceptional gloss. The root shows very nice detail. Absolutely great preservation and condition - extra sharp edges and tip - very clean. Authenticity guaranteed. Exceptional color!
NC362 SIZE: 1-7/8"
Learn More
Note - Adding 7 NC Red I. oxyrhinchus teeth in July 2020. Link to NC Red Oxyrhinchus teeth. - Isurus retroflexus$70.00
A rare TOP QUALITY, Isurus retroflexus tooth, a Longfin Mako, from the Meherrin River, No. Carolina. Upper jaw lateral tooth. Excellent copper red color with exceptional gloss. The root shows very nice detail with the typical distinct enameloid build up on the reverse side. Absolutely great preservation and condition - extra sharp edges and tip - very clean. Authenticity guaranteed. Exceptional color!
NC399 SIZE: 1-1/2"
Note - Adding 5 NC Red I. retroflexus teeth in July 2020. Link to NC Red I. retroflexus teeth.
Learn More - Hemipristis serra - BV$70.00
A colorful Top Quality Bone Valley Hemipristis serra shark tooth from Polk Co., Florida. Highest quality enamel. A blue colored crown with a white root. Exceptional color! An excellent white root. Great eye appeal. A colorful Bone Valley collector's Hemipristis tooth. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. You don't see these any more!
F264 SIZE: 1-3/16"
Note - Adding 17 new BV Hemipristis teeth in April 2025. -> Link to BV Hemipristis teeth
Learn More - Carcharodon carcharias - So. Carolina$70.00
A Top Quality Carcharodon carcharias, the Great White shark, tooth from So. Carolina. An upper jaw anterior tooth. Solid charcoal gray colored enamel and a solid dark gray colored root. Root is well preserved - very difficult to find in the Carolina GWs. Nice sharp serrations with a decent tip serration. An EXCELLENT Great White shark collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed.
SC911 SIZE: 1-1/4"
Adding 7 So. Carolina Great White teeth in June 2025. Link to SC Great White shark teeth.
Learn More - Phoebodus sp.$70.00
A rare, Top Quality Phoebodus sp., an extinct Phoebodontiform shark tooth, from the Paleozoic era in Indiana. An excellent primary cusp. Great color and articulation. A well preserved specimen. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. An excellent collector's tooth!
Age: Middle Mississippian (347 MYA); Harrodsburg Limestone Fm.
Location: Washington Co., Indiana
Z019 SIZE: 3/8"
Adding 30 US Paleozoic teeth in July 2025 --> Link to US Paleozoic teeth
Learn More - Phoebodus sp.$70.00
A rare, Top Quality Phoebodus sp., an extinct Phoebodontiform shark tooth, from the Paleozoic era in Indiana. An excellent primary cusp. Great color and articulation. A well preserved specimen. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. An excellent collector's tooth!
Age: Middle Mississippian (347 MYA); Harrodsburg Limestone Fm.
Location: Washington Co., Indiana
Z020 SIZE: 5/16"
Adding 30 US Paleozoic teeth in July 2025 --> Link to US Paleozoic teeth
Learn More - Petalodus alleghaniensis$70.00
A LARGE rare, High Quality Petalodus alleghaniensis, an extinct Petalodont shark tooth, from the Paleozoic era in Iowa. An excellent primary cusp. Great color and articulation. A well preserved specimen with some damage. No restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. An excellent collector's tooth!
Age: Upper Pennsylvanian (300 MYA); Herta Limestone Fm.
Location: Crescent, Pottawattamie Co., Iowa
Z030 SIZE: 1-7/16" wide x 1-3/4"
Adding 30 US Paleozoic teeth in July 2025 --> Link to US Paleozoic teeth
Learn More - Edestus heinrichi$70.00
A very rare, Top Quality Edestus heinrichi shark tooth, from Herrin, Illinois. This is a Paleozoic shark that lived in swamps that our now underground coal deposits. Excellent preservation, serrations, and serration detail. The Edestus shark would have an upper and lower tooth whorl that are vertically opposed. Research showed that they could use their opposing teeth in a scissor-like motion or a vertical whipping motion to cut prey. It is the first animal to cut vertically. A very strange looking and unique acting shark. Shark recreation image is credited to Julio Lacerdo. These rare teeth are Pennsylvanian age from Illinois. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed.
I23 SIZE: 1-7/8" w/ root (7/8" crown)
Adding 22 Edestus shark specimens in July 2025. Link to Edestus shark.
Learn More - Carcharodon (Isurus) hastalis$70.00
"The Color Collection - South of the River - Fire Zone" A TOP QUALITY, Carcharodon (Isurus) hastalis tooth with an excellent bright orange color (unique color)from the Sharktooth Hill area, Bakersfield, California. The root is very well preserved with a tan color. Very clean crown. Excellent overall preservation. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed.
ST040 SIZE: 1"
Adding 17 Sharktooth Hill Hastalis teeth in September 2026. Link to STH Hastalis teeth.
Learn More - Carcharodon planus$70.00
"The Ghost" A LARGE, TOP QUALITY, lower jaw Carcharodon planus tooth from the Sharktooth Hill area, California. Beautiful bright whote (unique color) crown with an excellent tan colored root. Excellent preservation. A Middle Miocene age tooth. No repair or restoration. Incredible color! An excellent collector's Mako tooth. Authenticity guaranteed.
ST324 SIZE: 1-9/16"
Adding 18 colorful Carcharodon planus teeth in September 2026. --> Link to Carcharodon planus teeth.
Learn More
