Authentic Fossil Shark Teeth for Sale
Find an impressive variety of high-quality shark teeth for sale, perfect for both serious collectors and enthusiasts of natural history. The selection features some of the most sought-after specimens, including massive Megalodon teeth, sharp Angustidens, and the distinctive Hemipristis, also known as the Snaggletooth. From the prehistoric Otodus to modern Great White and Mako shark teeth, each piece is legally collected and carefully inspected to ensure its quality and provenance.
Collectors can browse rare and unique finds, including the serrated Auriculatus, deep-water Cow shark teeth, and ancient Paleozoic specimens. Every item comes with a guarantee of authenticity, providing confidence in the value of the acquisition. Whether looking for a centerpiece for a display or a unique gift, this curated inventory offers a wide array of genuine fossilized teeth that connect you directly to the ocean's ancient predators.
- Palaeocarcharodon orientalis$145.00
A TOP QUALITY Palaeocarcharodon tooth from Morocco. An excellent lateral tooth. Gorgeous tan color. Extra large and irregular serrations along the cutting edge and cusps! Large side cusps. An incredible tooth! No repair. A top quality collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed.
M409 SIZE: 1-13/16"
Note - Adding 12 Palaeocarcharodon teeth in December 2024. Link to Palaeocarcharodon teeth.
Learn More - Otodus auriculatus - NC Red Site$145.00
A Quality copper red colored Auriculatus lateral tooth from the Meherrin River, No. Carolina. Excellent rare copper red colors. Very good preservation and condition. A good bourlette. The serrations are large including the tip. Complete root. A rare collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed.
NC105 SIZE: 2-1/2"
Note - Adding 6 NC Red Site Auriculaus teeth in January 2025. Link to NC Red Site Auriculatus Teeth
Learn More - Otodus angustidens - NC Red Site$145.00
A Top Quality copper red colored Angustidens tooth - an anterior tooth from the Meherrin River, No. Carolina. Incredible rare copper red colors! Highest quality enamel. No enamel peel. The bourlette is excellent. The serrations are sharp with a good tip. Excellent side cusps. The root is complete. No repair! A rare Angustidens collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed.
NC161 SIZE: 1-1/2"
Adding 7 new copper red site Angustidens teeth in January 2025. Link to NC Red Site Angustidens teeth.
Learn More - Carcharodon hastalis - NC Red Site$145.00
A fantastic, Top Quality copper-red Carcharodon hastalis tooth from the Meherrin River, No Carolina. Rare copper red color with high gloss. Best color. Highest quality enamel. Great preservation and condition - sharp edges and tip - very clean. No repair or restoration. Exceptional color! An excellent, rare collector's tooth! Authenticity guaranteed. Perfect tooth.
NC321 SIZE: 1-15/16"
Note - Adding 22 Red Site Hastalis Mako teeth in January 2025. --> Link to copper-red Makos
Learn More - Carcharodon hastalis - NC Red Site$145.00
A fantastic, Top Quality copper-red Carcharodon hastalis tooth from the Meherrin River, No Carolina. Rare copper red color with high gloss. Best color. Highest quality enamel. Great preservation and condition - sharp edges and tip - very clean. No repair or restoration. Exceptional color! An excellent, rare collector's tooth! Authenticity guaranteed. Perfect tooth.
NC320 SIZE: 1-3/4"
Note - Adding 22 Red Site Hastalis Mako teeth in January 2025. --> Link to copper-red Makos
Learn More - Carcharodon hastalis - NC Red Site$145.00
A fantastic, Top Quality copper-red Carcharodon hastalis tooth from the Meherrin River, No Carolina. Rare copper red color with high gloss. Best color. Highest quality enamel. Great preservation and condition - sharp edges and tip - very clean. No repair or restoration. Exceptional color! An excellent, rare collector's tooth! Authenticity guaranteed. Perfect tooth.
NC319 SIZE: 1-15/16"
Note - Adding 22 Red Site Hastalis Mako teeth in January 2025. --> Link to copper-red Makos
Learn More - Carcharodon hastalis - NC Red Site$145.00
A fantastic, Top Quality copper-red Carcharodon hastalis tooth from the Meherrin River, No Carolina. Rare copper red color with high gloss. Best color. Highest quality enamel. Great preservation and condition - sharp edges and tip - very clean. No repair or restoration. Exceptional color! An excellent, rare collector's tooth! Authenticity guaranteed. Perfect tooth.
NC318 SIZE: 2"
Note - Adding 22 Red Site Hastalis Mako teeth in January 2025. --> Link to copper-red Makos
Learn More - Carcharodon hastalis - NC Red Site$145.00
A fantastic, Top Quality copper-red Carcharodon hastalis tooth from the Meherrin River, No Carolina. Rare copper red color with high gloss. Best color. Highest quality enamel. Great preservation and condition - sharp edges and tip - very clean. No repair or restoration. Exceptional color! An excellent, rare collector's tooth! Authenticity guaranteed. Perfect tooth.
NC315 SIZE: 1-15/16"
Note - Adding 22 Red Site Hastalis Mako teeth in January 2025. --> Link to copper-red Makos
Learn More - Parotodus benedeni - Lee Creek$145.00
A TOP QUALITY very rare Parotodus benedeni tooth from the Lee Creek mine, Aurora, No. Carolina. Lateral tooth. The crown has extremely sharp cutting edges. Excellent blue color with a gray root and bourlette. The root is ~1/4" thick and shows no hydration cracks. This Parotodus tooth was found in the Pungo River Formation (Miocene age). No repair or restoration. A very special, rare collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed.
LC107 Size: 1+"
Note - Adding 6 Lee Creek P benedeni teeth in March 2025. Link to LC P. benedeni teeth
Learn More - Carcharodon hastalis - Bone Valley$145.00
A Top Quality, BLUE Bone Valley Mako shark tooth from Polk County, Florida with great color! Commonly referred to as Isurus hastalis, but renamed to Carcharodon hastalis as a Great White shark ancestor. Highest quality enamel. An excellent colored crown. Excellent color! Sharp cutting edges. An excellent tan colored root. Great eye appeal. A rare Bone Valley color collector's Mako tooth. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. You don't see these Mako teeth very often!
F102 SIZE: 2-1/8"
Note - Adding 8 new BV Isurus hastalis teeth in April 2005. -> Link to BV Isurus hastalis teeth
Learn More - Hemipristis serra - BV$145.00
A colorful Top Quality Bone Valley Hemipristis serra shark tooth from Polk Co., Florida. Highest quality enamel. An incredible black colored crown with a white root. Exceptional color! An excellent white root. Great eye appeal. A colorful Bone Valley collector's Hemipristis tooth. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. You don't see these any more!
F256 SIZE: 1-5/8"
Note - Adding 17 new BV Hemipristis teeth in April 2025. -> Link to BV Hemipristis teeth
Learn More - Otodus megalodon - Bone Valley$145.00
A HIGH QUALITY Bone Valley Chubutensis tooth from Polk County, Florida. An excellent BLACK colored tooth. Highest quality enamel. The bourlette is white color and complete. Excellent color! The serrations are large & sharp. Good serrations. The root is complete. An excellent Miocene Megalodon tooth. No repair or restoration! A collector's Chub tooth from Bone Valley! Authenticity guaranteed.
F007 SIZE: 2"
Note - Adding 8 Bone Valley Megalodon teeth in April 2025 --> Link to Bone Valley Megalodon Teeth
Learn More
