Parotodus benedeni Shark Teeth

Buried Treasure Fossils offers an incredible selection of rare Parotodus benedeni teeth for sale. The Parotodus is referred as the False Mako shark and is actually is not related to the Mako shark. We offer a few species including the large Parotodus benedeni teeth with museum quality specimens from many localities. These are rare fossil shark teeth that are seldom seen for sale! Authenticity guaranteed.
- Parotodus sp.$75.00
An Excellent pair of very rare Parotodus teeth. Anterior teeth. All wear is natural. Very difficult to find!
M578 (Right) SIZE: 1-1/16"
Learn More - Parotodus sp.$75.00
An Excellent and very rare Parotodus tooth from Morocco. Lateral tooth. Small amount of wear is natural. Eocene age. Very difficult to find! Authenticity guaranteed.
M582 SIZE: 7/8"
Learn More - Parodotus Benedeni - Ocean$75.00
A Rare, Atlantic ocean Parotodus benedeni tooth from the offshore Wrightsville Beach, No. Carolina. A robust tooth with a heavy root. This tooth appears to be a Yorktown Fm., Pliocene age tooth. No repair or restoration. A rare collector's tooth! Authenticity guaranteed. The Atlantic ocean Parotodus teeth are ultra rare! A must have collector's tooth.
NC544 SIZE: 2-1/16"
Adding 4 Atlantic ocean Parotodus benedeni teeth in August 2020. Link to Parotodus benedeni teeth.
Learn More - Parotodus sp.$60.00
An Excellent pair of very rare Parotodus teeth. Lateral teeth. All wear is natural. Very difficult to find!
M581 (Left) SIZE: 15/16"
Learn More - Parotodus benedeni - South Carolina$45.00
An very rare, Parotodus benedeni tooth from the Morgan River, So. Carolina. A Miocene-Pliocene age tooth from the Hawthorne Fm. Nice Red color. Lateral tooth. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. A very difficult tooth to locate.
SC871 SIZE: 1-5/8"+
Adding 15 So. Caroilna Parotodus benedeni teeth in May 2025. -> Link to SC Parotodus benedeni teeth.
Learn More - Parotodus benedeni$0.00
The PERFECT, very rare Parotodus benedeni tooth. An April 2019 Fossil of the Month. Lateral tooth. The crown has extremely sharp cutting edges. Exceptional light tan & blue color and preservation. An incredible wide bourlette. The root is ~5/8" thick and shows few small hydration cracks! Note- grooves on the sides of the root lobes - a Miocene tooth trait. One of the finest LC lateral Parotodus teeth that I have seen. This incredible Parotodus was found in the Pungo River Formation (Miocene age). No repair or restoration. A very special, rare collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed.
LC102 BoP Size: 2-7/16"
Learn More - Parodotus Benedeni$0.00
An Ultra Rare, LARGE copper-red Parotodus benedeni tooth from the Meherrin River, No. Carolina. Rare deep copper red color with exceptional gloss. Highest quality enamel. Great preservation and condition - extra sharp edges and needle-like tip - very clean & very rare. The root shows very nice detail and is complete and extra large with a little surface pitting. This tooth appears to be a Yorktown Fm., Pliocene age tooth. No repair or restoration. Exceptional color! An exceptional, rare collector's tooth! Authenticity guaranteed. The red site Parotodus teeth are ultra rare, and a lower anterior adds to its rarity! A collector must have tooth.
NC522 SIZE: 2-1/8"
Learn More - Parodotus Benedeni$0.00
An Ultra Rare, GEM, EXTRA LARGE copper-red Parotodus benedeni tooth from the Meherrin River, No. Carolina. Rare deep copper red color with exceptional gloss. Highest quality enamel. Exceptional preservation and condition - extra sharp edges and tip - very clean. The root shows very nice detail and is complete. This tooth appears to be a Yorktown Fm., Pliocene age tooth. No repair or restoration. Exceptional color! An exceptional, rare collector's tooth! Museum Quality. Best of the BEST! Authenticity guaranteed. The red site Parotodus teeth are ultra rare! A must have collector's tooth!
NC521 BoP SIZE: 2-11/16"
Learn More - Parotodus benedeni - Georgia$0.00
A very rare, Top Quality Parotodus benedeni lateral tooth with a massive root from the St. Mary's River, Georgia. A Miocene age tooth from the Hawthorne Fm. An August Fossil of the Month. An incredible red colored tooth! Highest quality enamel with sharp edges and a sharp tip! Root is massive,complete, nicely articulated, and has essentially no hydration crack. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. A very difficult tooth to locate from a loction that produces few Parotodus teeth. You never see top quality Parotodus teeth from the St. Mary's River! This is a very old collection piece.
G153 SIZE: 2-5/16"
Note - Adding three rare Georgia Parotodus teeth in August 2021. Link to Parotodus teeth.
Learn More - Parotodus benedeni - Virginia$0.00
A rare, Top Quality Parotodus benedeni shark posterior tooth, the extinct False Mako shark, from the Pamunkey River, Virginia. Nice tan & brown color. Excellent preservation and condition. A Miocene tooth. These teeth are not commonly found and seen. A rare collectors' tooth in high quality condition. Try finding one of these teeth! Authenticity guaranteed. I have never had a posterior tooth.
VA52 SIZE: 15/16"
Posting 22 scarce Virginia shark teeth in September 2021. Link to Virginia teeth.
Learn More - Parotodus benedeni - Georgia$0.00
An ultra rare, Top Quality Parotodus benedeni lateral tooth with a massive root from the St. Mary's River, Georgia. A Miocene age tooth from the Hawthorne Fm. An excellent red & gray colored tooth! High quality enamel with sharp edges. Root is massive, complete, nicely articulated, and has essentially no hydration crack. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. A very difficult tooth to locate from a loction that produces few Parotodus teeth. You never see top quality Parotodus teeth from the St. Mary's River. This is a very old collection piece.
G152 SIZE: 2-3/8"
Note - Adding two rare Georgia Parotodus teeth in November 2021. Link to Parotodus teeth.
Learn More - Parotodus benedeni - Georgia$0.00
An ultra rare, Top Quality EXTRA LARGE Parotodus benedeni lateral tooth with a massive root from the St. Mary's River, Georgia. A Miocene age tooth from the Hawthorne Fm. A November Fossil of the Month. An incredible red colored tooth! Highest quality enamel with sharp edges and tip. Root is massive, complete, nicely articulated, and has a small hydration crack. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. A very difficult tooth to locate from a loction that produces few Parotodus teeth. You never see top quality Parotodus teeth from the St. Mary's River. This is a very old collection piece. My largest and BEST St. Mary's red benedeni tooth!
G151 SIZE: 2-3/4"
Note - Adding two rare Georgia Parotodus teeth in November 2021. Link to Parotodus teeth.
Learn More












