Authentic Fossil Shark Teeth for Sale

A Top Quality Notorhynchus tooth - a Sevengill Cow shark, from the Pumunkey River, Virginia.  An upper jaw tooth with 4 primary cusps. This tooth has an excellent brown color with a tan root. Great color and preservation. This is a Miocene age, Calvert Formation tooth. An excellent collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed. 

VA81         Size: 11/16"

Note adding 11 Virginia Cow shark teeth in June 2022.  --> Link to Virginia Cow Shark teeth

A Top Quality Notorhynchus tooth - a Sevengill Cow shark, from the Randle's Cliff, Maryland.  An upper jaw tooth with 3 primary cusps. This tooth has an excellent blue - gray color with a tan root. Great color and preservation. This is an early Miocene age, Calvert Formation tooth. An excellent collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed. 

MD416         Size: 13/16"

Note adding 23 Maryland Cow shark teeth in June 2022.  --> Link to Maryland Cow Shark teeth

An Excellent olive tan colored Megalodon tooth from Florida. These Megs are Miocene age - about 10 MYA from the Bone Valley Fm. of Florida. Megalodon teeth are great for gifts, class room, or starting your fossil shark tooth or Megalodon collection.  Authenticity guaranteed.  Note - All "First Megalodon" teeth come with a 3"x4" Riker frame with label plus an identification card.  Note - Be sure to see all of our My First Megalodon offerings.

MFM42        Size: 1-15/16"

Note - Adding 12 new Bone Valley My First Megalodon teeth in Dec. 2022   -->   Link to My First Megalodon

A Top Quality Chilean Hexanchus griseus tooth from the Caldera Basin of Chile. This is an upper jaw tooth with three primary cusps. Excellent preservation and fantastic color. Near perfect cusps. These tooth was found in the Bahia Inglesa Fm. and is late Miocene to early Pliocene age. A scarce collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed. Unfortunately there are no more teeth coming from this site. This rare piece is from an old collection!      

C409U          Size: 15/16" Height

Note - Adding 18 new Chilean Hexanchus teeth in February 2023 ->  Link to Hexanchus Teeth 

A Top Quality Chilean Hexanchus griseus tooth from the Caldera Basin of Chile. This is an upper jaw tooth with three primary cusps. Excellent preservation and fantastic color. Perfect cusps. These tooth was found in the Bahia Inglesa Fm. and is late Miocene to early Pliocene age. A scarce collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed. Unfortunately there are no more teeth coming from this site. This rare piece is from an old collection!      

C407U          Size: 15/16"  Height

Note - Adding 18 new Chilean Hexanchus teeth in February 2023 ->  Link to Hexanchus Teeth 

A Top Quality Pseudocorax sp. shark tooth from the Essex Downs, Richmond, Queensland, Australia. Excellent preservation. Complete tooth. This tooth is Early Cretaceous (Late Albian age) from the Toolebuc Fm.  A rare collector's Pseudocorax sp. tooth. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. Australian fossil shark teeth are nearly impossible to source. This is a great specimen from an old collection.

AU19        Size: 7/16"

Note - Adding 26 Australian - New Zealand shark teeth in May 2024      Link to Australian - New Zealand shark teeth

An ultra rare, Top Quality Centrophorous squamosus (Gulper shark) tooth from the Motunau Beach, Canterbury, New Zealand. Incredible color and preservation. Complete tooth. This tooth is Middle Miocene (Waiauan) deep water shark from the Greta Siltstone Fm.  A rare collector's Centrophorous squamosus tooth. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. New Zealand fossil shark teeth are  impossible to source. This is a great specimen from an old collection.

NZ02        Size: 1/8"

Note - Adding 26 Australian - New Zealand shark teeth in May 2024      Link to Australian - New Zealand shark teeth

A very rare Top Quality Bone Valley Alopias superciliosus  (Bigeye Thresher) shark tooth from Polk Co., Florida. Highest quality enamel. An excellent black color with a white root. Great color!  Great eye appeal. A rare Bone Valley collector's Thresher shark tooth. No repair or restoration. Authenticity guaranteed. You never see Bone Valley Thresher shark teeth!

F172        SIZE: 1/2"  

Note - Adding 8 new BV Thresher shark teeth in June 2024.  ->  Link to BV Thresher teeth

A gorgeous, Schizorhiza stromeri rostal tooth from the phosphate mining area of Morocco. An extinct genus of schizorhizid sclerorhynchoid that lived during the Late Cretaceous. Exceptional quality! A very rare species! Note - All specimens are on their original matrix and have no repair or restoration. Excellent collector's teeth. Authenticity guaranteed.  

M1306          SIZE: 11/16"

A Top Quality, Carcharodon hastalis,  Mako shark tooth (upper anterior jaw tooth) from the Lee Creek mine, Aurora, No. Carolina. Note - This tooth exhibits the classic characteristic shape of the middle Miocene Mako teeth found both in the Lee Creek mine and the NC red site. I do not see this Mako tooth shape from other Miocene deposits. Possibly a hastalis species variation and it is referred to as the "narrow form". Maximum size is approximately 2". This tooth has a rich tan & blue crown and a tan colored root. Excellent colors!  Razor sharp cutting edge. Excellent preservation - note nutrient hole on root. It is a Miocene tooth from the Pungo River Fm. An excellent collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed.

LC326       Size: 1-7/8"

Note - Adding 30 new Lee Creek "Mako" teeth in February 2023.     Link to Lee Creek Mako Teeth.   

A Top Quality, Carcharodon hastalis,  Mako shark tooth (upper jaw tooth) from the Lee Creek mine, Aurora, No. Carolina. This tooth has a rich blue & tan crown and a light tan colored root. Excellent colors!  Razor sharp cutting edge. Excellent preservation - note nutrient hole on root. It is a Pliocene tooth from the Yorktown Fm. An excellent collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed.

LC322      Size: 2"

Note - Adding 30 new Lee Creek Big "Mako" teeth in February 2023.     Link to Lee Creek Mako Teeth.   

A Top Quality, Isurus oxyrinchus, the Shortfin Mako shark tooth (upper jaw anterior tooth) from the Lee Creek mine, Aurora, No. Carolina. This tooth has a rich blue & tan crown and a light brown colored root. Excellent colors!  Razor sharp cutting edge. Excellent preservation - note nutrient hole on root. It is a Pliocene tooth from the Yorktown Fm. An excellent collector's tooth. Authenticity guaranteed.

LC368        Size: 1-9/16"

Note - Adding 20 new Lee Creek Shortfin Mako teeth in February 2023.     Link to Lee Creek Oxyrinchus Mako Teeth.